Although zoning regulations would have permitted the architects to greatly enlarge the house by going upward, the McCalls did not want that much added space. So, instead, ABA proposed moving the front facade forward by about 8 feet and extending the floor plates. The solution preserved the rear garden and still allowed for a gracious entry court, while expanding the living area by about 20 percent, to nearly 2,700 square feet. The strategy made some rearrangement of the interior possible, with a combined kitchen, dining area, and living room extending from front to back on the first floor, a more equitable bedroom configuration above, and renovation of those bathrooms the McCalls had not previously updated. It also permitted insertion of floor-to-ceiling double-hung, divided-lite windows—a client stipulation. “Bettina said to us, ‘It is not a home if it doesn’t have lites,’” relates Abruzzo.

The windows, then, along with the house’s existing structure, became the jumping-off point for the design of the new front elevation. “Thinking of the project as a wood house, since it was historically of wood, informed all of the decisions,” says Abruzzo, explaining that the windows helped establish the gridlike organization of the stained cedar panels and battens, which sit above a new brick base. Brick is also used for a low wall at the sidewalk’s edge, which incorporates planters and seating, and for the entry court’s pavers. The material extends inside, down a short flight of steps, and into the lower level (which houses an office space and a study) and out to the backyard, where a terraced outdoor “room” steps up to the lush garden. The masonry, explains Abruzzo, made sense, not only for its contextual qualities but, in addition, for its ability—with the help of redundant drainage—to withstand intense rainfall or tidal flooding. (Though not technically in a high-risk zone, the house’s proximity to the river concerned the clients.)

The architects also carried the new front facade’s logic to the inside walls to create grids with the baseboards, trim, and moldings—all from standard lumber—and provide a framework for hanging art. All-white walls and kitchen millwork, along with white oak floors (in many areas original), complement the light that streams in from the new, tall windows, and from an enlarged skylight over the existing stair to the second level.

ABA’s moves, from expanding the house just a few feet forward, to combining typical materials in unexpected ways, have produced a project that is at once surprising and familiar. Stick House, Brick Garden is sympathetic to its neighborhood’s roots, yet is light-filled, comfortable, and contemporary.